| Platinum | Helvetia Tavern |
| Gold | Little Big Burger |
| Silver | Mr. Bento |
| Bronze | Five Stars Family Burger |
| Top Pick | Backwoods Brewery |
| Top Pick | Bumper Burger |
| Top Pick | Chin's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Hillsboro Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Killer Burger |
| Top Pick | Wilson's Cafe & Sports Bar |