| Platinum | Meraki Pop |
| Gold | The Artfull Garden and Company |
| Silver | Le'Stuff Antique Mall |
| Bronze | Cindy's Hallmark Shop |
| Top Pick | Bennett Urban Farm Store |
| Top Pick | Gifts A Gogo |
| Top Pick | Hill Theater Antique Mall |
| Top Pick | Krelly Designs |
| Top Pick | Next Level Pinball Shop & Museum |
| Top Pick | Tuesday Morning |