| Platinum | Westside Pizza House |
| Gold | Jersey Girl Pizza |
| Gold | The Rock Wood Fired Pizza |
| Silver | Society Pie |
| Bronze | MOD Pizza |
| Top Pick | Deep Space Brewing |
| Top Pick | Midway Firehouse Pizza |
| Top Pick | Old Chicago Pasta & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizzario |
| Top Pick | Schmizza Pub & Grub |